top of page

Big Bonus Backfire

Movement Mortgage is pursuing two Chicago originators who joined in 2022 and received more than $1 million in sign-on payments.

When rates rose, their production fell from about $36 million a month to about $4 million, and their branch lost money. Movement fired them in 2023 and demanded repayment. An arbitrator has ruled in favor of Movement, and the company is now asking a federal court to enforce the award.


This case connects what the hiring company expected from the branch to what the branch actually produced after the sign-on. 

  • A sign-on payment is the hiring company's investment in future production. The company pays up front for volume it expects the branch to deliver.

  • In this case, the payment reflected the roughly $36 million a month these originators averaged before they joined; what Movement received was closer to $4 million. 

  • When expected production arrives, the investment earns its return for both sides. 

  • When it does not, the company turns to the contract to recover its money, and the originator learns how much of that risk the agreement placed on their shoulders.


Is this case a warning? Yes.

A large sign-on payment feels like income, but it is often an advance you have not yet earned. If the market turns, if your production falls, or if the company lets you go, that money can come back to you as a debt. Movement is also seeking 8% interest from April 2023. At that rate, interest alone could add more than $300,000. More than 3 years after losing their jobs, these two originators still face the bill.


Before you sign, get these answers in writing:

  • Is the payment a forgivable loan, an advance, or a bonus you keep outright?

  • When does it vest, and on what schedule?

  • What triggers repayment: resignation, termination, missed production targets, or branch losses?

  • Does repayment apply if the company terminates you without cause, or if the branch is terminated?

  • Do branch losses increase what you owe?

  • Who decides a dispute, where, and at what interest rate?


Have an attorney review the agreement before you sign it, and do not spend the money until it vests.


Source: Martinez, A. (2026, November 10). Movement seeks $1.2M clawback: Vet signing bonus terms now. National Mortgage News. https://www.nationalmortgagenews.com/news/movement-mortgage-seeks-over-1-million-in-lo-clawbacks


Disclaimer: I am a CPA, not an attorney, and nothing in this post is legal advice. The facts come from public reporting by National Mortgage News; I have not reviewed the agreements or the arbitration record. The connections I draw are my own sketch, not findings from any record, and the parties may tell a different story. Have an employment attorney review any sign-on agreement before you sign it. These views are mine alone.


About Dr. Schell:

Dr. Andy Schell, Ph.D., DBA/MBA, MSML, CPA/CFF, CMB


Dr. Schell is CEO, Managing Partner, and Co-Founder of Mortgage Banking Solutions and the Founder of MBS Financial Services ("MBS"), based in Austin, Texas. Dr. Schell is known for his ability to turn "vision into reality" and "chaos into order" by finding creative solutions to the challenges his clients face, addressing Revenue Stability, Technology Enhancement, Financial Management, and Workflow Efficiency.


He has 4 decades of experience as a strategist, directing the activities of both small and large groups of employees, including in mortgage lending at Bank of America. His leadership knowledge extends from his hands-on experience and his academic training in his MBA, his master's degree in leadership, and his doctoral work to examine employee dynamics given leader stimulus


To find out more information about MBS's services, please click HERE


To contact Dr. Schell, click HERE

Find more information at

DoctorSchell@MBS-Team.com ; (512) 501-2812

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Journal: Blog2
bottom of page