top of page

Beyond Logos: Why Being Right Is Not Enough

24 minutes ago
5 min read

By Andy Schell, PhD, DBA, CPA, CFF


Business and Professional Communication Quarterly, the peer-reviewed journal of the Association for Business Communication published by SAGE, recently published my article, "Beyond Logos: Teaching Persuasion to Accounting Professionals Through the ELEVATE Framework." The article introduces ELEVATE, a framework designed to help accountants and finance professionals move a technically correct recommendation from analysis to acceptance. Read the full article on SAGE Journals.


The Problem: Being Right Is Not the Same as Being Accepted

Accounting programs train students to arrive at the right answer. Yet a tax strategy, internal control recommendation, valuation conclusion, or technology investment still requires approval from a client, executive team, board of directors, or audit committee. At that point, success depends on persuasion as much as technical accuracy.


That training devotes extensive attention to analysis but comparatively little to persuasion. As a result, many accountants learn persuasive communication on the job, if they learn it at all. When an audience resists a recommendation, the instinctive response is often to provide more evidence. That approach works when the analysis is incomplete. It fails when the analysis is already sound and the obstacle lies elsewhere: the audience does not yet trust the communicator, cannot follow the technical terminology, or does not see how the recommendation advances its own objectives.

The article distinguishes proof from persuasion. Proof asks whether an analysis is correct.


Persuasion asks whether a particular audience accepts that analysis at a particular moment based on its own concerns and priorities. A 1993 survey of 287 practicing CPAs by Bayou and Panitz found that accountants attributed persuasive success primarily to the quality of their information and ranked the accountant and the firm last among the sources of influence. I developed ELEVATE to challenge that assumption and broaden how accounting professionals think about persuasion.

The Seven ELEVATE Practices

The framework consists of seven communication practices that help move an audience from trust to action.

1.     Establish connection and credibility beyond credentials. Credentials demonstrate competence, but audiences also decide whether a communicator is trustworthy and attentive to their interests.

2.     Lead with business impact. Explain what the finding means for the audience before discussing methodology.

3.     Explain evidence through concrete and relatable examples. A chart, analogy, or familiar comparison often communicates more effectively than a table filled with data.

4.     Value-frame the recommendation around the audience's goals. Connect the recommendation to outcomes the audience already wants to achieve.

5.     Anticipate and address objections before they arise. Resolve likely concerns before the audience raises them.

6.     Translate technical content into business language. Replace specialized terminology with language the audience already uses.

7.     End with a single clear recommendation. Present one preferred course of action rather than several equally weighted alternatives.


Figure 1. The ELEVATE framework. Practice 6 (Translate) runs throughout the sequence rather than occupying a single step.


Why the Order Matters

The seven practices move audiences through four conditions: trust, understanding, acceptance, and action. An audience does not weigh a recommendation until it trusts the communicator. It does not understand a recommendation until the message focuses on what matters to the audience and is easy to process. It does not accept a recommendation until it sees how the proposal serves its goals and the communicator answers its concerns. It does not act until the communicator presents one clear choice.


The sequence is a default pathway rather than a rigid formula. The article identifies circumstances that can alter the order. An urgent audit issue, for example, can come first, and stating it candidly builds credibility in its own right. An audience that already trusts the communicator from earlier work needs less trust-building. An audience with limited time or technical knowledge needs a simpler explanation before it can evaluate the recommendation.


Grounded in Classical Rhetoric and Modern Research

ELEVATE draws on Aristotle's three persuasive appeals: ethos (credibility), pathos (audience values), and logos (evidence and reasoning). Accounting education traditionally emphasizes logos, but effective persuasion requires all three appeals. ELEVATE incorporates ethos, pathos, and logos throughout the communication process.


The framework also aligns with Cicero's five canons of rhetoric: inventio (discovery, traditionally translated as invention), dispositio (arrangement), elocutio (style), memoria (memory), and actio (delivery). By comparison, familiar frameworks such as AIDA and the Minto pyramid address message organization. Organization matters, but organization alone does not solve communication failures rooted in credibility, audience values, or technical complexity. An accountant can follow a presentation structure perfectly and still fail if the audience does not trust the messenger or cannot understand the message. In those situations, changing the order of the content does not solve the underlying problem.


Each ELEVATE practice rests on an established body of research. Source credibility research found that audiences judge a communicator's believability more by whether the communicator cares about their interests than by competence. Field studies found that memos stating the conclusion first took 17% to 23% less time to read and produced better comprehension. Research on visual and verbal learning supports pairing a chart with a spoken explanation. Framing research shows that an audience judges the same recommendation differently when the communicator presents it as a gain to capture or a loss to avoid. Inoculation research supports answering objections early. Research on how audiences process messages explains why unfamiliar jargon weakens a sound argument. Research on decision conflict shows that people facing several comparable options often postpone the choice, while one named recommendation gives them a clear decision to make.


What It Looks Like in Practice

The article includes four worked examples drawn from advisory engagements. In one example, a controller seeks board approval for a $40,000 system upgrade related to an internal control deficiency. The original draft begins with a discussion of a "material weakness in journal entry approval controls" and several paragraphs describing methodology. The revised version begins by explaining that one person could move funds without a second review, quantifies the cost of the solution, and explains the consequences of delaying action. A single sentence translates the technical issue into business terms and leads with business impact.


The underlying analysis did not change. The recommendation did not change. Only the communication changed. Yet the revised message addresses the board's decision-making needs far more directly. That distinction captures the central argument of the framework: technical correctness and persuasive effectiveness are related, but they are not the same thing.


Who the Framework Serves

For CPAs, controllers, CFOs, and advisors, ELEVATE provides a practical process for preparing board presentations, client recommendations, audit committee communications, and management reports. For business communication instructors, it organizes concepts already taught in many courses, including audience analysis, direct organization, and plain language, into a single framework that can also support assessment through a structured rubric.


I teach the framework in continuing professional education (CPE) courses for practicing CPAs, and it adapts to accounting, finance, and business communication programs.


The article also describes the framework's limitations. ELEVATE emerged from decades of professional advisory experience and draws upon established research traditions, but the framework itself has not yet been evaluated through a controlled empirical study. It remains a proposition awaiting broader validation, and the article outlines opportunities for future research.


Conclusion

Technical expertise remains essential, but expertise alone rarely secures agreement. Professionals succeed when audiences trust them, understand their message, accept their reasoning, and feel prepared to act. ELEVATE provides a practical framework for guiding audiences through those stages.


Read the Full Article

Schell, A. (2026). Beyond Logos: Teaching persuasion to accounting professionals through the ELEVATE framework. Business and Professional Communication Quarterly. https://doi.org/10.1177/23294906261500733

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Big Bonus Backfire

Movement Mortgage is pursuing two Chicago originators who joined in 2022 and received more than $1 million in sign-on payments. When rates rose, their production fell from about $36 million a month to

 
 
 

Comments


Journal: Blog2
bottom of page